Teagan Milar
Corrections in America
10-19-2015
Prison Paper
Restrictive housing is a form of imprisonment where an inmate is kept isolated from the general population. People in restrictive housing are usually spending around 22 to 24 hours a day in a small cell with minimal human contact or meaningful activity. The cells are often six by ten feet and have only a bed, a toilet, and a sink. Most cells do not have windows or much light making it a very hostile environment. Recreation time, if given, happens alone in a small caged area. In general, restrictive housing is meant to control inmates' behavior, manage threats, or punish rule violations. However, it's become a heavily debated topic in corrections today because of its psychological and ethical consequences.
One of the most serious concerns about restrictive housing is how it affects people with mental illness. Many studies have found that inmates in restrictive housing are more likely to have serious mental health conditions. Some were already diagnosed before placement, while others developed symptoms because of the isolation and lack of stimulation. Chapter 6 of Restrictive Housing in the U.S. Prisons and Jails explains that “the harmful effects of isolation are not limited to those with serious mental illnesses; even psychologically healthy inmates can experience anxiety, panic, hallucinations, and depression after prolonged periods of confinement” (National Institute of Justice, 2016, p. 3). The lack of social interaction and natural light can cause people to lose their sense of time and reality, which can lead to long-term damage. Despite these issues, prison administrators continue to use restrictive housing for several reasons.
There are both pros and cons to restrictive housing. On one hand, it is an immediate way to control violence and restore order in dangerous situations. It is often used to protect vulnerable inmates who might be targeted by others, to separate people considered dangerous, or to punish those who break serious rules. Also, it also gives administrators time to investigate incidents or calm down tense situations. On the other hand, it has negative effects on mental health and the potential for abuse make it controversial. According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics report Use of Restrictive Housing in U.S. Prisons and Jails, 2011–2012, “an estimated 20 percent of inmates who had spent time in restrictive housing reported psychological distress” (Beck, 2015, p. 4). Many experts believe that long-term isolation can actually make prisons less safe because it increases anger, trauma, and difficulty adjusting once people return to the general population. Studies have shown that people coming out of restrictive housing often struggle with reintegration.
In my opinion, restrictive housing should be a last resort. Understandably, prison staff need ways to control violence and protect people, but isolation for long periods feels inhumane and unnecessary in many cases. Prisons should focus more on programs that help inmates manage their behavior through therapy and education rather than relying on isolation. Restrictive housing might make sense for a short period in more serious cases, but it should include mandatory mental health check-ins, access to treatment, and opportunities for engaging activity. In the NIJ research, one report highlights that “prolonged confinement without social interaction or meaningful activity undermines the possibility of rehabilitation and can make future reintegration into society more difficult” (Restrictive Housing in the U.S. Prisons and Jails, Chapter 9, p. 8). If the goal of prison is rehabilitation, then restrictive housing in its current form does not support or represent that goal.
Overall, restrictive housing has become one of the most challenging issues in the correctional system. While it may sometimes be necessary for safety, it often causes lasting harm to the people who experience it. Reform efforts reduce the use of solitary confinement, especially for mentally ill inmates, and replace it with more effective alternatives that promote both security and human dignity.
Work Cited
Beck, A. J. (2015). Use of restrictive housing in U.S. prisons and jails, 2011–2012 (NCJ 249209). U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
National Institute of Justice. (2016). Restrictive Housing in the U.S. Prisons and Jails: Issues, Challenges, and Future Directions (Chapter 6).
National Institute of Justice. (2016). Restrictive Housing in the U.S. Prisons and Jails: Issues, Challenges, and Future Directions (Chapter 9).