Teagan Milar
POL 1090
Professor Pace
August 2, 2026
Analytical Essay
The United States Constitution has remained as the foundation of the American government for more than 235 years. However during this time the nation has experienced social, political and technological changes. Because society has changed so dramatically, judges must decide how to apply a centuries old document to modern day problems. Different methods of constitutional interpretation attempt to solve this problem, including originalism, textualism, and pragmatism. While each approach has its strengths, I argue that pragmatism provides the best method of constitutional interpretation because of its emphasis on balance between the constitution's original principles with modern realities. This allows courts to adapt to changing circumstances and protect constitutional rights in ways that remain meaningful for contemporary society.
Pragmatism is an approach to constitutional interpretation that focuses on applying the Constitution in a way that best fulfills its underlying purposes. Rather than relying exclusively on the original understanding of the plain meaning of the text , pragmatic judges consider constitutional history, legal precedent, and evolving social conditions (Breyer, 2005). This does not mean judges ignore the Constitution's languages, instead, they recognize the Constitution's established function in a changing nation. The Framers intentionally wrote many conditional provisions in broad language, such as “equal protection,” “due process,” and “unreasonable searches,” suggesting that they had already expected future generations to apply these principles in the means they see fit (National Constitution Center).
One of the greatest strengths of pragmatism is its ability to preserve the relevance of the Constitution over time. Modern Society is completely different from the country that existed in 1787. Societal advances have created legal questions that the Farmers never imagined. If judges were to interpret the Constitution only according to eighteenth-century expectations, many of the intended protections would fail to address modern issues. Pragmatism allows judges to remain faithful to the Constitution's principles while simultaneously recognizing that those principles must be applied in contemporary circumstances (Posner, 2008). The flexibility of pragmatism enables the Constitution to remain a living framework.
The reasoning in the case Brown v. Board of Education reflected a pragmatic understanding of the Constitution. Rather than focusing on whether individuals who adopted the Fourteenth Amendment specifically intended to prohibit segregated public schools, the Court explained the actual effects of segregation had on the children. Chief Justice Earl Warren explained that separating students based on race was harmful to the children's educational opportunities and violated the constitutional promise of equal protection (Brown v. Board of Education, 1954). The Court recognized that constitutional equality required more than just identical facilities on paper, equal treatment needed to be put into practice.
On the other hand, an originalist approach might have reached a different conclusion. Originalism argues that judges should solely interpret constitutional provisions according to their original public meaning at the time they were adopted (Scalia, 1997). Some originalists argue that because the individuals who ratified the Fourteenth Amendment accepted segregated schools, the amendment was not originally understood to prohibit school segregation. Under a strict originalist analysis, the Court may have been more likely to leave the issue to state legislatures rather than declaring segregation unconstitutional. Although originalism provides important safeguards against judicial overreach, it is often too rigid to address mondrian constitutional challenges. Constitutional language such as “equal protection” was intentionally written in broad terms, suggesting that it was designed to apply beyond expectations of certain time periods (Sunstein, 1996). Overall, if courts interpreted constitutional rights only according to historical practices, progress on racial equality may have been delayed.
Furthermore, critics of pragmatism argue that it gives judges too much discretion and allows them to substitute their personal beliefs for constitutional law. This criticism does raise legitimate concern because courts should not function as legislatures. However, pragmatism does not permit judges to ignore the Constitution altogether. Pragmatic judges rely on constitutional text, historical context, legal precedent, and careful legal reasoning (Posner, 2008). The difference is that they also consider how decisions affect lives and whether those decisions fulfill the Constitution’s fundamental purpose and values. Additionally, judicial discretion exists under every method of interpretation to some extent. Pragmatism simply acknowledges that applying broad principles requires thoughtful judgement rather than extreme historical analysis.
Brown v. The Board of Education illustrates why practical consequences matter. Had the Supreme Court ignored the damaging effects segregation segregation had and instead only focused on historical legal practices, racial segregation may have persisted much longer and had even more extreme effects on society. The Court's decision strengthened the Constitution's guarantee of equal protection and ensured that the rights reflected genuine equality.
In the end, the Constitution has endured for more than two centuries because its principles are broad enough to guide future generations. While originalism and textualism contribute valuable perspectives, pragmatism provides the most effective approach to conditional interpretation today. Pragmatism enables courts to protect rights while balancing constitutional text, history, and precedent. The Supreme Court's decision in Brown v. Board of Education demonstrates how this approach can advance the conditions promised of equality even though historical practices suggest otherwise. As America continues to evolve, pragmatism offers the most effective and flexible interpretation of the Constitution while maintaining its core purpose.
References
Breyer, S. (2005). *Active liberty: Interpreting our democratic Constitution*. Alfred A. Knopf.
Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483 (1954). https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/347/483/
National Constitution Center. (n.d.). Constitutional interpretation. https://constitutioncenter.org/
Posner, R. A. (2008). *How judges think*. Harvard University Press.
Scalia, A. (1997). *A matter of interpretation: Federal courts and the law*. Princeton University Press.
Sunstein, C. R. (1996). *Legal reasoning and political conflict*. Oxford University Press.